Your employees should not have to wait until December to hear that their work matters.
Yet many will. The year end message arrives, perhaps with a mince pie and a paragraph about “an extraordinary year”, and people read it with the polite scepticism of someone opening a Christmas card from a distant relative. It’s kind. It’s also obvious that it was written in one sitting, for everybody at once.
The tempting fix is to do the same thing better: a bigger event, a more heartfelt speech, a gift with the company logo on it. I’d resist that. A once a year gesture, improved, is still a once a year gesture. It mostly benefits the person giving it.
Appreciation is a working habit, not an event
Think about how you manage cash. Nobody reviews it annually, announces the result at a party, and then leaves it alone until next winter. You look at it regularly because it changes regularly, and because problems found early are cheaper than problems found late. Appreciation behaves in much the same way. It needs to be current to be useful, and it loses most of its value when it’s stored up and spent in bulk.
There is a difference between genuine appreciation and the occasional public kind, and it comes down to a few plain properties. Genuine appreciation is specific, timely, and delivered in a way that suits the person receiving it. A speech at the party is performance. A sentence on a Tuesday afternoon is leadership. Applause lasts ten seconds. A private word that names exactly what someone did can be remembered for years.
That last point matters more than it sounds. Some people enjoy being thanked in front of the whole team. Others would rather chew glass. A leader who praises everyone publicly, regardless of temperament, is serving their own sense of occasion rather than the individual. Appropriate is a judgement call, and the only way to make it well is to know your people, which tends to happen in the ordinary run of one to ones and team catch ups, not at the annual dinner.
Small acknowledgements in those ordinary meetings do the heavy lifting. A minute at the start of a one to one to say what you noticed this week. A line in a team meeting that credits the person who did the unglamorous bit. None of it needs budget or ceremony.
People feel valued when somebody has plainly been paying attention, and attention can’t be scheduled for December.
Recognise the work behind the numbers
Most organisations are very good at celebrating the number. Revenue is up, the target was hit, the contract was signed. The sales lead gets the credit, and often deserves it.
But a dashboard is a torch in a dark room. It lights one patch very clearly, and everything outside the beam looks as though it isn’t there. The person in customer service who spent forty minutes calming a furious customer doesn’t appear in the beam. Neither does the operations colleague who spotted that the same supplier invoice was about to be paid twice, or the administrator who keeps the diary, the paperwork, and the small deadlines moving so that nobody else notices they exist.
These contributions don’t show up in a report because their best outcome is that nothing happens. The complaint doesn’t escalate. The payment isn’t duplicated. The meeting starts on time. Good work in these roles is largely invisible by design, which makes it the easiest work in the business to take for granted.
I’d ask leaders to go looking for it deliberately. Once a week, ask what went wrong that didn’t, and who stopped it. You’ll usually find a name, and it’ll rarely be the name on the quarterly slide.
This is also a commercial point, not a sentimental one. Revenue is a result. The processes, people, and daily discipline underneath it are the cause. A leader who only acknowledges results is telling the team which part of the work counts, and everybody else quietly adjusts their effort accordingly.
Appreciation builds trust, and trust surfaces the truth
When effort is acknowledged, people feel connected to the organisation, and that has a practical consequence. They become more willing to offer an idea in a meeting, mention a worry before it becomes a crisis, and tell you that the new process isn’t working.
The mechanism is simple. People decide, usually without announcing it, whether speaking up is worth the risk. If the only time they hear from a leader is when something has gone wrong, the sensible conclusion is to keep your head down and your concerns to yourself. If they’ve been thanked for flagging a problem, credited for an idea, and listened to without being interrupted, the calculation changes.
Psychological safety is the technical term for this, and it sounds more complicated than it is. It’s built from three ordinary behaviours: listening properly, treating people fairly, and giving credit where it’s due. The last of these is the one most often neglected. An idea raised by a team member that reappears two weeks later as the manager’s own costs more than any bonus could repair. People notice, and they remember, and they stop offering.
An organisation where nobody thanks the person who raises the problem will soon have nobody raising problems. You’ll find out eventually. It’ll just be from a customer.
The same pattern runs through collaboration, retention, and problem solving. Colleagues who feel recognised help each other more readily, because credit isn’t treated as scarce. People who feel noticed are harder to lose to a competitor offering a modest pay rise. And teams that can say “I think we’ve got this wrong” in week two don’t have to say it in month six.
Make it specific, or don’t bother
“Good job” is the paper cup of recognition. It holds something briefly and then it’s gone, and nobody remembers which one it was.
A better formula has three parts. Say what the person did. Say why it mattered. Say what difference it made. That’s all, and it takes about fifteen seconds.
Compare the two versions. “Thanks for dealing with the complaint, good job.” Against: “You rang that customer back before they’d escalated it. They told me they’d been about to leave, and they’re staying. That also saved the team a very unpleasant afternoon.”
The second version tells the person exactly which behaviour to repeat. It also shows that you understood the situation, which is half of what makes praise believable.
The same applies to teams. If a group has cut an approval step out of a slow internal process, name the step, say how much waiting it removed, and say who no longer has to chase whom. (I realise “who no longer has to chase whom” is not the most elegant sentence in this article, but anyone who has chased an approval will understand it perfectly.) A team that hears that level of detail knows its work has been understood, not merely noticed.
Appreciation doesn’t replace accountability
The strongest objection to everything above is that regular praise makes people comfortable. People are paid to do their jobs, the argument goes, and thanking them for it lowers the bar. Worse, a leader who is always positive can’t then deliver a hard message without it sounding like a betrayal.
There is something in that, but only for a certain kind of appreciation. Vague, constant, unconditional praise does dull standards, because it carries no information. If everything is “brilliant”, the word has stopped meaning anything.
Specific appreciation does the reverse. It tells people exactly what good looks like, which makes the gap between good and not good visible. And it builds the credit a leader needs to have honest conversations. Someone who has been told clearly and truthfully what they do well is far more able to hear where they need to improve. Feedback from a person who has never acknowledged your effort sounds like criticism. Feedback from a person who has sounds like information.
So the two belong together. Recognising effort doesn’t excuse poor performance, and it shouldn’t be used to soften it into invisibility. Employees should know where they stand on both counts: what they’re doing well, where the standard isn’t yet being met, and what you expect next. Clear expectations are a form of respect. Hiding them behind pleasantries is not.
Praise is honest only if criticism is available. Criticism is credible only if the praise was real.
If you want somewhere to start, do it before Friday. Think of one thing someone did this week that nobody above them noticed. Go and tell them what it was, why it mattered, and what changed. Then put the year end hamper order on hold until you’ve done it a few more times.